What are the economic drawbacks of using biofuels?

Growing crops for biofuel can have serious environmental drawbacks, such as the deforestation in Indonesia caused by palm oil plantations.
Growing crops for biofuel can have serious environmental drawbacks, such as the deforestation in Indonesia caused by palm oil plantations.
Robert Nickelsberg/Getty Images

Switching the world's energy consumption habits from petroleum-based fuels to biofuel, or plant- and renewable source-based fuels, makes good sense in some ways. Unlike oil reserves, biofuel crops are renewable -- after this year's harvest, plant next year's fuel source. Also, the emissions from many biofuels contain fewer harmful particles and chemicals than petroleum fuel emissions. The biggest selling point for biofuels, though, is the argument that cleaner-burning fuel, made from a source that absorbs carbon dioxide as it grows, can help us cut down on the emissions that are contributing to global climate change.

But the biofuels most likely to be produced on a large scale, such as corn in the United States, sugar cane in Chile and palm oil in Indonesia, carry significant drawbacks. Producing them in an economical manner that supports widespread biofuel use can cause serious harm to the environment. And the economics of producing these fuels in a way that capitalizes on their environmental benefits could make them too expensive to produce and distribute on a large scale.

Regional Products, Global Issues

Biofuel crops are like any plants; they need the right combination of sunlight, water, nutrients and time to grow. And like houseplants or backyard garden vegetables, some of these crops do better in certain regions than others.

This can cause a major dilemma for advocates of plant-based fuel. A biofuel farmer in an arid region such as the American Southwest would have to invest heavily in irrigation to grow enough corn to produce an economically viable quantity of ethanol [source: McKenna]. The alternative, having a diesel-powered truck haul fuel in from another region, presents transportation costs -- and significant emissions -- that limit the fuel's advantage over petroleum diesel [source: Pimentel].

Further complications develop when biofuel for one nation is produced in another nation. Palm oil plantations in Indonesia, for example, have come under fire for causing massive deforestation and significant greenhouse gas emissions. Their purpose? To produce clean biodiesel for European drivers. This outsourcing of biofuel production simply moves the pollution, rather than eliminating it [source: Rosenthal].

Economic Ripple Effects

Ethanol production could cause the price of corn to rise, resulting in a ripple effect that ends with consumers paying more for corn.
Ethanol production could cause the price of corn to rise, resulting in a ripple effect that ends with consumers paying more for corn.
iStockphoto/Thinkstock

The economics of producing biofuel can affect more than just the fuel industry. Since many popular biofuel crops are also popular food sources, expanded biofuel production has the potential to cause fluctuations in food prices.

Consider a farmer who feeds his livestock a mixture that includes corn. If an ethanol producer starts buying corn from the same distributor the farmer uses, the increased demand could cause prices to rise. The farmer, knowing that the extra cost of feed will hurt his bottom line, protects his business by passing that cost along as higher prices for his livestock. The butcher, grocer or restaurateur who purchases his chickens, cattle and pigs pays more for the meat, which ultimately translates into a higher price tag on dinner for the end consumer [source: Carey].

While one could argue that increased demand will encourage farmers to make more productive use of their land, that solution to this trickle-down problem could lead to its own problems, such as overuse of fertilizer and monoculture farming that's overly susceptible to pests and disease [source: Altieri].

Overall Costs

Perhaps the worst economic drawback of biofuels is that, according to some researchers, producing biofuel burns through too many resources to make it feasible.

In a 2005 study, researchers measured the total resource input that went into producing biodiesel from a number of popular crops. They measured the gas burned by tractors plowing the fields, the energy it took to produce and spread fertilizer, the water for irrigation and the energy it took to move it to the fields, and a seemingly endless list of other expenses -- both financial and in terms of greenhouse gas emissions -- that went into producing biofuel. At best, some biofuels studied required 27 percent more energy to produce than they contained. In the worst case, sunflower oil-based biofuel took more than 100 percent more energy to produce than it contained [source: Pimentel].

In the face of these costs, some biofuel advocates argue that new and future technologies, along with economies of scale, will reduce these ratios. Until then, however, it appears that biofuels still have significant economic drawbacks to overcome on their way to replacing petroleum-based fuels.

To learn more about biofuels, click to the next page.

Related Articles

Sources

  • Alexander, C. et al. "Biofuels and their Impact on Food Prices." Purdue Extension. September 2007. (Jan. 14, 2011)http://www.extension.purdue.edu/extmedia/ID/ID-346-W.pdf
  • Altieri, Miguel A. "Modern Agriculture: Ecological impacts and the possibilities for truly sustainable farming." University of California, Berkeley. July 30, 2000. (Dec. 13, 2010)http://www.cnr.berkeley.edu/~agroeco3/modern_agriculture.html
  • Burpee. "Growing Zone Information." 2010. (Dec. 11, 2010)http://www.burpee.com/gardening/content/gygg/growing-zone-information/growingzoneinfo.html
  • Carey, John et al. "Food vs. Fuel." Bloomberg Businessweek. Feb. 5, 2007. (Nov. 15, 2010)http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/07_06/b4020093.htm
  • Golden Fuel Systems. 2007. (Dec. 13, 2010)http://www.goldenfuelsystems.com/index.php
  • Journey to Forever. "Oil Yields and Characteristics." (Nov. 19, 2010)http://journeytoforever.org/biodiesel_yield.html
  • Lau, Michael H. et al. "The Economics of Ethanol from Sweet Sorghum Using the MixAlco Process." Agricultural and Food Policy Center, Texas A&M University. Aug. 11, 2006. (Jan. 14, 2011)http://www.afpc.tamu.edu/pubs/2/446/RR%2006-2.pdf
  • McKenna, Phil. "Measuring Corn Ethanol's Thirst for Water." MIT Technology Review. April 14, 2009. (Nov. 15, 2010)http://www.technologyreview.com/energy/22428/page1/
  • Mellon, Margaret and Jane Rissler. "Environmental Effects of Genetically Modified Food Crops -- Recent Experiences." Union of Concerned Scientists. June 12-13, 2003. (Dec. 13, 2010)http://www.ucsusa.org/food_and_agriculture/science_and_impacts/impacts_genetic_engineering/environmental-effects-of.html
  • Naylor, Rosamond L. et al. "The Ripple Effect: Biofuels, Food Security and the Environment." Environment. November 2007. (Jan. 14, 2011)http://www.environmentmagazine.org/Archives/Back%20Issues/November%202007/Naylor-Nov07-full.html
  • Pimentel, David and Tad W. Patzek. "Ethanol Production Using Corn, Switchgrass, and Wood; Biodiesel Production Using Soybean and Sunflower." Natural Resources Research. March 2005. (Jan. 14, 2011)http://www.springerlink.com/content/r1552355771656v0/
  • Rosen, C.J. and B.P. Horgan. "Preventing Pollution Problems from Lawn and Garden Fertilizers." University of Minnesota. 2009. (Dec. 11, 2010)http://www.extension.umn.edu/distribution/horticulture/dg2923.html
  • Rosenthal, Elisabeth. "Once a Dream Fuel, Palm Oil May Be an Eco-Nightmare." The New York Times. Jan. 31, 2007. (Nov. 16, 2010)http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/31/business/worldbusiness/31biofuel.html?adxnnl=1&adxnnlx=1290625375-G4EOxMpw99oBdvPcW6DvCw
  • Tsuneishi, Scott. "E85 Vs Conventional Gasoline - Tech Knowledge." Import Tuner. April 2009. (Dec. 13, 2010)http://www.importtuner.com/tech/impp_0904_e85_vs_conventional_gasoline/index.html
  • United States Department of Agriculture. "Adoption of Genetically Engineered Crops in the U.S." July 1, 2010. (Dec. 13, 2010)http://www.ers.usda.gov/Data/BiotechCrops/